I got this because I was using a non-waterproof mascara. I have oily skin and at the end of the day my mascara would be under my eyes. I hate having to use make up remover, it’s just an extra step and you also have to purchase pads to take it off. This is the perfect amount of resistant. It does not flake or run. You can splash it with water (I’ve never tried to submerge my face) and at the end of the day it easily washes off with my face soap, no residue! I have sensitive skin and eyes and it doesn’t bother me. It’s buildable, it doesn’t clump, and there are not so many harsh ingredients (almost like the hippie cousin of the CG mascara in the orange tube) I love it!!

Nice application, still smudges.
This is a nice mascara, however it is not smudge free. The wand has the right angle which helps in application. Still on the hunt for mascara that separates and does not smudge...

Love this mascara, it stays on ALL DAY! But also washes off so gently. It's a little spendy but it's worth it. I have it on subscription monthly. I don't think I'll ever change it up at this point. My eyes are super sensitive and this is the only mascara that doesn't make my eyes hurt